So it turns out that Ashley Benson has a secret actress twin named Grace Phipps

Forget the endless Pretty Little Liars mysteries and even trying to work out who the hell Charles actually is, because Ashley Benson has got a real life puzzle that needs solving.

In fact, everybody on Instagram is pretty much losing their minds over how much newly blonde actress Grace Phipps – who you might remember for her role as April Young in The Vampire Diaries – looks like Ashley.

Although we did just say that Grace is blonde, she hasn’t always been and before she hit the bleach nobody ever really mistook her for Ashley.
This is Grace Phipps holding what looks like a cappuccino. Or is it Ashley Benson holding a latte? Or is Grace Phipps holding Ashley Benson’s cappuccino? OR IS IT ASHLEY HOLDING A MOCHA?